"If I Were You" Does Screwball Canadian Comedy
March 2013
Featuring adultery without the naughty bits, a wife-mistress rivalry, and a couple of nursing-home deaths, If I Were You is a screwball comedy for Canadians—not LOL funny, but as crazy as you might expect Toronto to get. Using whip-smart wordplay from writer-director Joan Carr-Wiggin (A Previous Engagement), Marcia Gay Harden does a star turn in versatility. Forget "mash-up"—Harden works many modes, side-by-side and within each other. So polite that she races off in embarrassment after spotting her husband (Joseph Kell) at a compromising lunch with a gorgeous young thing, her Madelyn turns events to her advantage and ends up with three men drooling over her—a nice brains-trumps-cute trick from a starchy matron in sensible heels—even as she fends off Leonor Watling's charmingly ditzy Lucy.
Read More
Film Review: If I Were You
March 2013
An unholy alliance is formed when Madelyn (Marcia Gay Harden) horrifyingly spots her husband Paul (Joseph Kell) having dinner with a heretofore unsuspected and quite younger girlfriend, Lucy (Leonor Watling), an aspiring actress of no discernible talent. Madelyn follows Lucy home and prevents the dippy, distraught girl from committing suicide, never telling her who she really is. She gets the details of her husband’s affair from Lucy, and describes her own experience with a straying partner. A completely ignorant Lucy observes that people screw up their own lives but would never willfully destroy someone else’s, so the two make a pact to give each other advice with the caveat that they both must do exactly what they are told.
Read More
The Terrific Marcia Gay Harden Movie You Didn't Get to See in Theaters
February 2013
As Oscar night draws closer, the prognosticators have declared a neck-and-neck-and-neck race between Jennifer Lawrence ( The Silver Linings Playbook ), Jessica Chastain ( Zero Dark Thirty ), and Emmanuelle Riva ( Amour) for the Best Actress prize. Forgive me, however, for feeling that the competition is a bit rigged this year. In the romantic farce If I Were You ,University of Texas alumna Marcia Gay Harden delivered a performance every bit as accomplished and unexpected as those that were Oscar-nominated—and yet she never even got the chance to compete.
Read More